Expert article
Edit 23 May 2023
by Nils Scheffler

Consolidation of the public-citizens cooperation for the provision of affordable housing

Workshop housing cooperative.
One of the most innovative aspects of the ‘Yes, We Rent!’ project is to coproduce affordable rental housing through a collaboration between the municipality and its citizens by founding a tenants’ cooperative. In animating citizens to become active agents in the provision of affordable housing, ‘Yes, We Rent!’ touches a key issue for public housing policy today.
Share
Quote

We wanted to explore how the collaboration between tenants could lead to the generation of affordable housing. Is it possible that housing policies do not just work in a top-down manner with the government as the sole provider of affordable housing? Could we move towards a system in which the community -through collaboration with administrations or by itself- could self-generate affordable housing in the rental market? This is the main challenge, the main proposal and the main vision of the project.

Alberto Terrones, Mataró City Council.

In addressing this challenge, the ‘Yes, We Rent!’ project has strived to bring together two types of stakeholders with different orientations and cultures: on the one hand, citizen and rights-to-housing movements with their bottom-up and grassroots logic; and on the other, the municipality with its more top-down and administrative approach. Both sides bring different skills and capacities into play to achieve more together. Exploring and testing the potential of this kind of cooperation is the main contribution of the project ‘Yes, We Rent!’ to innovation of public housing policies. At the same time, ‘Yes, We Rent!’ represents an exception in public-cooperative collaboration. While public support for housing cooperatives mostly happens in the form of ceding land and buildings, support for Bloc Cooperatiu consisted in the municipality transferring temporary control over privately owned flats. This support provides the cooperative with seed capital and at the same time with an opportunity to develop its capacity in the management of housing stocks.

In the framework of the ‘Yes, We Rent!’ project, the city of Mataró accompanied and supported the creation of a tenants’ cooperative through citizens to manage the flats they mobilised during the project. These flats have become the foundation of an affordable housing stock under the management of the tenants’ cooperative that will continue to incorporate new flats for affordable housing after the end of the EU-project ‘Yes, We Rent!’.

After the process for attracting owners to the affordable housing scheme had begun, in February 2020, the Yes We Rent! partner Fundació Unió de Cooperadors made a call to citizens to participate in the constitution of a cooperative. Around 50 citizens went to a first meeting, which soon led to a core group of ten who withstood the difficulties that the pandemic imposed to develop the cooperative. Of this group, 2 people were eventually contracted to become the first technical team to accompany the process of constitution of the tenants’ cooperative Bloc Cooperatiu. For further information read the ‘zoom-in’: Mataró’s Tenants Housing Cooperative for affordable rental housing.

There was a contradiction between the usually lengthy process of setting up a housing cooperative and the context of an EU-funded project, with its expectation to have a cooperative running within a relatively short time. The restrictions imposed due to the pandemic also made it difficult for the founding members of the cooperative to meet, to build trust among each other and to develop the project further.

Another particularity is that ‘Yes, We Rent!’ - as a municipality led project, set up a cooperative “from above”, with the city council being present from the outset and providing support accompaniment. These atypical conditions created frictions, but they helped to put the focus from the outset on the project as a pilot for testing the potential of tenant's cooperatives as an instrument of public housing policies.

The engagement of the founding members together with the public support and the resources made available through the EU project helped Bloc Cooperatiu to take off very quickly. For legal reasons, the municipality could not become a member in the cooperative, as initially planned, which means that other legal forms of institutional or contractual cooperation had to be defined for the time after the end of the EU-funded project.

With the end of the EU-funded pilot phase, less resources are available for the municipality and at the cooperative Bloc Cooperatiu to invest in the partnership. To support the further development the city of Mataró has given 50,000 € to the Fundació Unió de Cooperadors, that is funding two staff positions of Bloc Cooperatiu for one more year; this to continue the management of Bloc Coperatiu and the acquired flats of the project. The city of Mataró also considers to start joint campaigns in the future to acquire further flats for the "Yes, we rent!" housing scheme. The city will also continue to inform owners about the "Yes, we rent!" scheme and the corresponding support possibilities by the city and the entities of public interest. Further possibilities would be helping with the technical capacities to manage affordable housing, detect new flats and conduct renovations.

At the same time, the citizen-led partnership in Mataró needs to be broadened into an ecosystem involving more actors for the provision of affordable housing. With political commitment on the side of the municipality to further engage in the co-production of affordable housing, and a diversification of non-profit actors on the housing market, public support can extend to new instruments such as the cession of buildings and land for citizen-led social housing or the creation of new credit lines.

Currently, to support further public-citizens cooperation in the provision of affordable housing, the following scheme is currently undergoing political consultations:

Organisations can apply for the label of "entity of public interest". To become an “entity of public interest”, an organisation has to prove, among others, that it mobilises rental flats for rent below 20 % of the average rent index. In addition, it has to prove that flats are rented out without any discrimination. Further, the management and organisation of the entity has to be transparent and participative. The organisation must be willing to allow verification of compliance with the requirements at any time. The label of "entity of public interest" can also support the organisation in its public image.

At the same time, owners, who rent or make available their flats to “entities of public interest” (on a non-discriminatory basis, 20 % below the rent index), can apply for the following incentives:

1.      Local property tax reduction or inheritance tax reduction (for people that inherit a flat)

2.     Grant for insurance about rental guarantee during the contract period and any legal expenses in this context

3.      Grant or credit aid for the (energy-oriented) renovation of the flat

This scheme provides incentives for owners to co-operate with "entities of public interest" in the provision of affordable housing in Mataró.

The "Yes, We Rent!" project is an innovative attempt to bring together citizens and the municipality to co-produce affordable rental housing. The project has established a tenants' cooperative called Bloc Cooperatiu that manages the flats mobilized during the project and has become the foundation of an affordable housing stock. The project has explored the potential of collaboration between citizens and the municipality in the provision of affordable housing and tested the feasibility of tenant cooperatives as an instrument of public housing policies. The project has encountered difficulties, including the pandemic and the usually lengthy process of setting up a housing cooperative. However, the founding members' engagement and the public support, including the resources made available through the EU project, helped the tenants’ cooperative Bloc Cooperatiu to take off quickly. The citizen-led partnership for affordable housing production in Mataró needs now to be broadened into an ecosystem involving more actors for the provision of affordable housing. With political commitment on the side of the municipality to further engage in the co-production of affordable housing, and a diversification of non-profit actors on the housing market, public support can extend also to new instruments such as the cession of buildings and land for citizen-led social housing or the creation of new credit lines.

Other news from this project

Aerial view of Mataró

Final journal of the UIA project 'Yes, we rent!'

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
People participating in a workshop

4 key activities to mobilise empty flats for affordable rental housing - zoom-in °3

Mataro's city council has developed an incentive scheme and untertaken four key activitites to mobilise private empty flats for the affordable rental ...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Final event "Yes, we rent!", Mataro, 22.09.2022

Mataró concludes its project ‘Yes, we rent!’ – the final event

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
The Yes We Rent! project wins the Fair Financing for Affordable Housing award

The Yes We Rent! project wins the Fair Financing for Affordable Housing category under European Responsible Housing Awards

The Yes We Rent! project to transform the rental housing market wins the Fair Financing for Affordable Housing award at the third European Responsible...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Balcony of a renovated flat with two white chais

Mataró’s Tenants Housing Cooperative for affordable rental housing - zoom-in °2

Mataro's tenants housing cooperative, Bloc Cooperatiu, provides affordable rental housing reactivating private vacant flats. This article describes ho...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Yes We rent conference

Yes We rent participates in a conference to present its model as an alternative to traditional access to housing.

Mataró City Council and the Maresme County Council organised in February three conferences under the title "Youth and Access to Housing" to address th...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Yes We Rent! established its Advisory Board and held its first meeting on the 28th October 2021.

Yes We Rent! established its Advisory Board and held its first meeting on the 28th October 2021.

Yes, We Rent! aims to mobilise empty flats in the city that would be allocated to the members of a new tenants’ cooperative that had to be set up with...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Aerial view of Mataró from see site

Yes, we rent! Journal 3: the seven major implementation challenges

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Co-housing
Housing
Housing cooperative
Urban poverty
Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

Recommendations for the establishment of a new housing cooperative to provide affordable housing in Mataró

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Housing
Measuring changes

The challenge of evaluating an innovative housing project

The city of Mataró has developed an innovative housing project to provide affordable housing in the private rental market. In order to learn from the ...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Circular economy
Co-housing
Housing
Housing cooperative
Logo Bloc Cooperatiu

A day to remember: 18.2.21, Mataro has a new offspring – the tenant housing cooperative BlocCooperatiu!

On 18th of February 2021, the notary LOPEZ & ALBIOL formally approved Mataro’s new tenants housing cooperative ‘BlocCooperatiu’. Dedicated residents o...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Co-housing
Housing
Housing cooperative
‘Yes, We Rent!’ Journal 2: Reactivating the private empty flats has started!

‘Yes, We Rent!’ Journal 2: Reactivating the private empty flats has started!

UIA Expert Nils Scheffler updates us how “the acquisition of empty flats as well as the training of troubled adolescents for the renovation of the emp...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

video conference about housing cooperative

A look ahead - What does 2021 bring for the 'Yes, we rent!’ project

COVID-19 and its effects continue to be a reality in Mataró, but also for the project 'Yes, we rent!'. ...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Co-housing
Education
Energy retrofitting
Housing
Housing cooperative
Vulnerable groups
Yes, We Rent! – Training vulnerable young adults

Mataro Zoom-in 1: Vacant flats for a better future of vulnerable young adults - The ‘Yes, We Rent!’ training programme

Yes, We Rent! – Training vulnerable young adults...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

First owner signed contract to bring his flat to the ‘Yes, we rent!’ housing scheme

First owner signed contract to bring his flat to the ‘Yes, we rent!’ housing scheme

On 28th of September the time had come. The first owner, Antonio Martínez, signed the contract to make his empty flat available to the 'Yes, we rent!'...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Adolescent renovating flat

Do not bury your head in the sand - especially despite COVID 19!

Interview with Laura Font Mela, director of Salesians Sant Jordi-PES Mataró, how they have successfully shifted their physical training program for tr...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Education
Housing
Jobs and skills in the local economy
housing is a human right

Cities engaging in the right to housing

Urban Innovative Actions (UIA) and URBACT are joining forces to push the right to housing...
UIA Article
Affordable housing
Journal 1 for ‘Yes, We Rent!’: Mataro’s first steps

Journal 1 for ‘Yes, We Rent!’: Mataro’s first steps

UIA Expert Nils Scheffler explains that “so far, no serious challenges for the project have arisen. There is a quite strong political and administrati...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Picture of the "Yes We Rent!" Website

Owners, make your empty apartments available!

In order to acquire apartments for the 'Yes, we Rent!' housing scheme, the first information campaign measures were started and first apartments visit...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Circular economy
Co-housing
Energy retrofitting
Housing
Housing cooperative
housing is a human right

Cities engaging in the right to housing

Urban Innovative Actions (UIA) and URBACT are joining forces to push the right to housing...
UIA Article
Affordable housing
"Yes, we rent" project picture

Mataró has kicked off its project for a larger audience: The Learning event!

Mataró faces the problem of “people without flats and flats without people”....

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain

Affordable housing
Circular economy
Co-housing
Co2 reduction
Energy retrofitting
Housing
Housing cooperative
Rehabilitation works within the Yes We Rent! project

Salesians Sant Jordi starts training 12 youngsters in rehabilitation works within the Yes We Rent! project

Yes We Rent! is a project coordinated by Mataró City Council (SPAIN), to try to bring solutions to the dramatic lack of affordable rental housing in t...

Yes We Rent! - Leveraging vacant private property to build up a cooperative affordable housing scheme

Housing

Mataró - Spain