Expert article
Edit 15 December 2022
by Levente Polyak

Connecting bottom-up ideas to owners and funders: The RADAR Real Estate Forum in Ravenna

RADAR Real Estate Forum
Urban transformation, especially in the form of large urban development projects, is often seen as primarily top-down, regulated by public administrations and implemented by private developers. Traditionally, small companies, cultural initiatives and civil society organisations are excluded from these development processes, because of their limited financial capacity, operational competence or experience in implementation. However, in the past decades, community-led real estate development has become an important element of urban regeneration processes in Europe. The many buildings that became vacant after de-industrialisation, the fall of the Berlin Wall or the 2008 economic crisis have become a learning ground for many civic initiatives that transformed these spaces according to the needs of their communities. Building on these experiences, community-led urban initiatives in Berlin led a long campaign in the 2010s, advocating for a new set of criteria when selecting the winning bid for the redevelopment of public properties. Partly inspired by this campaign, Paris led dozens of cities to redesign their competition mechanisms within the Reinventing Cities programme, inciting cities to engage with a broader range of actors when redeveloping urban areas.

Ravenna chose a more organic approach to assure that bottom-up initiatives can also have a place around the negotiating table. In Ravenna, the DARE project, funded by the Urban Innovative Actions programme, has been working on connecting the top-down and bottom-up approaches of urban regeneration, by coupling initiatives that aim at reusing vacant buildings and unused land in the city’s Darsena area with property owners and financiers. In this article, UIA expert Levente Polyak explores the milestone event of this ambition, the RADAR Real Estate Forum.
Share

​The air is filled with the smell of jasmine as I approach the Darsena through one of the railway crossings that connects the old city with the former port area. It is late April, and it feels like Ravenna consists of two parallel cities. In the historical centre crowds of schoolchildren are marching towards the Dante Museum or one of the city’s Byzantine chapels. The squares where school groups stop to take a rest in-between these visits are immediately turned into playgrounds, with their loud chatter reviving the old town.

Gathering in front of the Almagià
Gathering in front of the Almagià. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

In the meanwhile, beyond the railway tracks, another kind of crowd is gathering. In front of the basilica-like structure of the Artificerie Almagià, a former sulphur warehouse located in Ravenna’s Darsena area, an odd group is forming. After convening around the building, they depart towards the Candiano Canal, businessmen and women in suits walking alongside activists, students, researchers and journalists. They stop every now and then to listen to their guide’s explanation, before continuing their stroll through the post-industrial landscape of the former port.

This is the second day of RADAR, the real estate forum organised by the DARE project. RADAR was designed to “connect the people with the ideas to the people who own the properties and those with the financial ability to support these projects,” explains Martina Manna of KCity, co-organiser of the event.

The tour begins
The tour begins. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

Equipped by the inspiration and perspectives offered by the presentations of the day before, participants set themselves to explore the untapped potential of the Candiano Canal. I join one of the three groups exploring the different aspects of the Darsena, following the project’s ideator, Saveria Teston. We walk along the Canal in the constantly changing weather that manifests itself with a particular force in this open, ample part of the city. Every now and then, we pass by a vacant building or land that inspired citizens to project their needs and desires into these spaces. We move past a parcel near the canal where some students designed a skate park before reaching the former shooting range which is conceived to host an orangery in the future. We leave the promenade along the canal for the district’s hinterland where large green areas and housing blocks complete the industrial cityscape. We turn to Via Pag where a group of students envisioned a set of artisan workshops, inspired by a set of pavilions lining up along the street. On the way back to the Almagià, we take a stop at the cigar-shaped buildings where a group of citizens imagined a museum of the sea.

The walk only lasts an hour but it completely absorbs its participants. Walking together across an area makes an important difference in the process of rethinking the possibilities of the Darsena. After decades of successive masterplans and generic discussions about the area, ideas for the Darsena become much more tangible when they’re connected with dedicated people as well as with specific buildings and sites. “Seeing where development will take place or projects might be implemented is definitely inspirational but is also very much needed from an investor’s point of view,” says Francesca Passeri, deputy director of the European Crowdfunding Network, confirming my feelings. 

Walking along the potential development sites is also a way to initiate conversations and build connections. As participants stop in front of a building and they let their imagination soar, cold negotiations about the future of a space suddenly turn into a joint exercise of creativity. In these peripatetic discussions, walking in pairs or in small groups of three or four, interlocutors no longer carry competing visions. As they fix their eyes on the horizon in the Darsena’s extensive space, the strollers’ imaginations converge towards a shared perspective for the area.

Potential development site in the Darsena
Potential development site in the Darsena. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

***

The state park, the orangery, the artisan workshops or the museum of the sea are only a few of the many proposals for the Darsena that local residents, activists and innovators conceived as a response to the municipality’s call last Autumn. In order to accompany these proposals and help them build synergies with each other, a process consisting of several steps was designed by Multilab, a temporary association of enterprises led by KCity and composed by NomismaLabsus and Politecnica, from mapping existing initiatives to identifying the tactics for the Darsena.

A walk in the future orangerie
A walk in the future orangery. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

RADAR is a cornerstone of this process. The real estate forum held in Ravenna’s Darsena on 26-27 April 2022 was conceived as an “interface between ideas, owners and potential investors, explains Saveria Teston, “a link between these worlds that are really different.”  The event was designed to bring together investors and real estate advisors, representatives of the construction sector, industry and SMEs, researchers and third sector operators, innovators, property owners and representatives of the Ravenna Municipality.

Getting on board all these actors is not an easy task. Indeed, RADAR was preceded by months of organisation. “We did a big stakeholder engagement process,“ recalls Martina Manna. “We have been talking to the property owners since October last year. We know that some property owners are interested in selling, others are welcoming ideas.” In these new networks forming around the Darsena, the municipality has a central role; as Saveria Teston underlines, the municipality is “the key interlocutor all developers want to have at the table.” 

RADAR was designed with three components in mind, “Imagine,” “Explore” and “Connect.” The event was opened with a set of lectures (“Imagine”) on social innovation, digital transition, climate change and the attraction of talent in a mid-size city, “with speakers from outside the project and outside Ravenna to stimulate a wider approach,” recollects Emanuela Medeghini, DARE’s project coordinator on behalf of the Ravenna Municipality. Besides introducing some key themes, keywords and concepts to the audience, the role of these lectures in launching the event was to “create a common ground to discuss together about the future, starting from the proposals with a more complex idea of the city in mind,” specifies Saveria Teston.

This common ground was brought to fruition on the second day of RADAR. After the walk with concerned project initiators, property owners and funders (”Explore”), the discussions unfolding between the strollers were brought back to the workshop tables for the third part of the event, “Connect.”

Imagine: Lectures for inspiration in the Almagià
Imagine: Lectures for inspiration in the Almagià. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

***

After an hour of exploration, we return to the Almagià building. The choice of the location to accommodate RADAR is conscious decision. The Artificerie Almagià in itself is a symbol of urban regeneration: it has brought creativity and culture in an area previously known for its hardships, and strengthened the links between the Darsena area and the historical centre of Ravenna.

In the building’s immense theatre hall, three large workshop tables are installed, in comfortable distance from one another, in order to guarantee that participants can concentrate on their own discussions. I join the table moderated by Francesca Passeri. She carefully gives the voice to all participants around the table, and invites everyone to reflect on the challenges of one another. Her focus is on the financial sustainability of the proposals presented by the activists, researchers and entrepreneurs around the table. “We’re trying to integrate the participation element not only in the design of the area but also in the funding of initiatives that will be implemented in the area,” she explains to me, “to make sure that the new activities are not only relevant for the citizens but also sustainable at the economic level.”

Workshop in the Almagià
Workshop in the Almagià. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

There is nothing arbitrary in the way participants sit around the different table: they are invited to specific working groups according to a well-calculated order. The groups are designed to facilitate the creation of synergies between the different project proposals and connect them with the relevant property owners and potential funders, if they hadn’t met yet during the walk and previous meetings.

“We had studied the project ideas and identified where they could have connections when intervening in the same area or facing similar problems,” recalls Emanuela Medeghini. These synergies are conceived to lead to the Darsena tactics, “integrated and coordinated sets of feasible projects which can guarantee the greatest possible effectiveness in the development of the regeneration process by jointly pursuing a shared development scenario,” continues Medeghini.

Projects that work on temporary use, will all have to deal with the legal framework and characteristics of temporary use, as described in the POC Tematico Darsena, the city's regulation for the Darsena area: short-term use contracts, regulations allowing access, safety measures adapted to short-term needs, setting up a temporary infrastructure, etc. Other projects seek large investments and therefore need to develop financing mechanisms. Some initiatives are connected through their locations, concentrating, for example, on the Candiano canal and the possibilities of the water. Others can generate synergies along the research and innovation projects, cultural and sports initiatives or inclusion activities they propose. Once these synergies are established, initiators are invited to resubmit their proposals in cooperation with others, the winning tactic to be selected via a public vote.  

Closing the workshop
Closing the workshop. Photo (cc) Levente Polyak

***

Following a long period without public encounters, RADAR was the first event of the "LIVE" series dedicated to help citizens explore the Darsena area. After years of isolation caused by the pandemic, it was essential for the project to bring together the future protagonists of the Darsena area. Further postponed because of the municipal elections, RADAR seems to have come in the right moment, with ideas mature enough for hands-on discussions around them, but still open enough to be able to merge together or connect with each other.

I leave Ravenna with a feeling of accomplishment and the sensation that there is a momentum that DARE can build on. Before heading to the train station, I meet with Saveria Teston to ask her about her feelings after the event. Visibly worn after the long days of organisation and relieved at the same time, she tells me about the feeling of having liberated a spirit from the bottle. “The stakes are higher now because people start thinking now that we can achieve things,” she acknowledges; “now we have the responsibility to stay close and work together with our partners to transform the ideas into real projects.” 

Other news from this project

The DARE partnership

DARE Journal #3: The multiple legacies of DARE

DARE is an innovative urban regeneration project that instead of focusing uniquely on the physical environment, has invested in the skills and ambitio...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Presentation of tactics for the Darsena

DARE Ravenna Zoom-in #3 - Co-designing a future vision: The selection of a tactic for Ravenna's Darsena

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Empaville session. Photo by DARE

From proposing to collaborating and voting: participatory tools for the Darsena

Digital democracy or e-democracy tools have been frequently used to overcome the trust gap between citizens and public administrations, by lowering th...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Event to present the tactics of the Darsena. Photo: Levente Polyak

Towards a tactic for the Darsena: co-designing urban development scenarios

Participatory urbanism has become a buzzword in the past decade. Participation in urban processes can range from consultation on single issues, to co-...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Industrial site in the Darsena. Photo by Levente Polyak

From crowdfunding to community finance: Funding the Darsena’s bottom-up transformation

Financing territorial redevelopment is largely seen as a top-down process with priorities defined by public administrations at the local, regional or ...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
DARE's digital environment. Image by DARE

Building an inclusive digital environment: data collection, management and literacy in Ravenna’s Darsena area

Digital platforms and tools have been increasingly central elements of urban planning and design. With the proliferation of digital instruments using ...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Site visit in Ravenna's Darsena area. Photo by Levente Polyak

After RADAR: long-term perspectives for development in the Darsena

Property development is a long-term genre, with processes between vision, programming, design, development and inauguration that may take years if not...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Making of DarsenaRavenna.it. Image by DARE

The Making of Approdo Comune: A digital environment for the regeneration of Ravenna’s Darsena

Changing the narrative of a neighbourhood can be just as important in urban regeneration as changing its physical fabric. However, imposing a story on...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Site visit in Ravenna's Darsena area. Photo by Levente Polyak

After RADAR: long-term perspectives for development in the Darsena

Property development is a long-term genre, with processes between vision, programming, design, development and inauguration that may take years if not...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Interview with Emanuela Medeghini

DARE Ravenna Zoom-in #2 - Towards a tactic for the Darsena

The Urban Innovative Actions-funded project DARE is a non-conventional urban regeneration project that instead of focusing uniquely on the physical en...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Storymaps

Modelling the Darsena: Storymaps or the digital heritage of a neighbourhood

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
View of Darsena in summer

DARE Zoom-in #1: Narrating urban transformation - a digital platform for Ravenna's Darsena

In this first Zoom-in for the UIA project DARE, Levente Polyak explores the digital platform conceived to support the transformation of Ravenna's Dars...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Night at the Candiano Canal

DARE Journal #2: Unfolding stories of the Darsena

DARE is an innovative urban regeneration project that instead of focusing uniquely on the physical environment, invests in the skills of its inhabitan...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
The Candiano Canal

DARE Journal #1: The Project’s Approach

The DARE (Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities) project connects urban regeneration w...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
Map of policies. Image (c) Multilab

Ravenna Mapping Darsena: In search of visions, lost and found

Many urban regeneration schemes focus on architectural interventions or masterplans that aim to transform the social fabric of an area through shaping...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy

Digital transition
View of the Darsena

Re-appropriating Ravenna’s waterfront: towards a collective story of transformation

Ravenna's Darsena area has been a delicate spot on the city’s map. After a process of deindustrialisation and a series of attempts to regenerate the f...

DARE - Digital Environment for collaborative Alliances to Regenerate urban Ecosystems in middle-sized cities

Digital transition

Ravenna - Italy